I’m pretty happy with engagement in the Fediverse.

Awesome!

True

Lemmy has about 40,000 monthly active users. Lemmy.world accounts for about 15,500 of that. That’s about 40%.

This site currently measures the concentration of user data for active users: in the Fediverse, this data is on servers (also known as instances); in the Atmosphere, it is on the PDSes that host users’ data repos. All PDSes run by the company Bluesky Social PBC are aggregated in this dataset, since they are under the control of a single entity. Similarly, mastodon.social and mastodon.online are combined as they are run by the same company.

True

So why does everyone keep referring to Bluesky as decentralized or even comparable to the fediverse

They call it marketing, I call it propaganda.

PDSes only store user data. These are full instances that can be used to browse the network. The idea is to make your account really yours. Bluesky is hosting most of them. But there are some people who do it on their own.

But bluesky controls much more important components in the network, namely the Relay and AppView.

If Bluesky decides to cut off your PDS you are pretty much alone.

Bluesky is pretty much a centralized platform like Twittler.

I suppose PDS instances are included: https://github.com/bluesky-social/pds

This is dumb on a different level

I don’t have any problems with the FP4.

Relationally

root access

Data shouldn’t be organized hirarchically.

That may be true but it makes the Lemmyverse much more robust in the long term.

I don’t care if I have to subscribe to multiple similar communities or see some posts multiple times, as long as not one or just a few people control the whole discourse.

That’s why redundant communities are important. Admins and mods make different decisions and heavily shape culture in the community.

Many don’t like it but I think it’s a beautiful feature of the Fediverse.

Basically “try to sue us”

Why not doing both? Supporting more independent platforms and advocating for pro-consumer laws

Still a very inefficient OS

Wouldn’t that be fruit missing?